Owls, Deer, a Ghostie
and 69 Carp
Four anglers. Four lakes. Four very different weeks, and some honest words from the bank.
Four sessions. Four different lakes, four different regions, four completely different types of week. One of them produced 69 carp. Another gave an angler their biggest ever fully scaled. A third delivered 30 fish in sub-zero conditions that would have beaten most venues before the week started. And the fourth had owls calling overhead while the rods were out, horses and donkeys as background noise, and a ghosty coming out to finish off a 17-take session.
What these four reviews have in common isn't the fish count or the weather or the style of fishing. It's that each angler came off the water with something to say: something specific, something genuine, something worth hearing before you decide where to go next.
The best reviews aren't the ones that say "brilliant" and move on. They're the ones that paint a picture of what a week actually looked and felt like.
Below, four anglers report back. In their own words where it matters, shaped into something readable where it helps. The lakes are all on the Majestic Carp portfolio. The sessions were real. The numbers check out.
Picardy (Oise), France · 2h from Calais
Noute 1
6 acres · Record 60lb · ~450 carp · 5 swims · 2h from Calais
Sixty-nine carp in a week. That's the headline from this session at Noute 1. Before you ask, yes, the best ones were attached. This is what Noute does when conditions play ball: it produces numbers that most other venues of similar size simply can't match. With around 450 carp spread across 6 acres of gravel-bottomed water, the fish density gives you a genuine chance of a prolific session.
The stock here is diverse in the best way: mirrors, commons, grass carp and koi, all fighting hard thanks to an abundant natural food supply. The average sits around 25lb, with carp between 30 and 45lb not uncommon, and the record at 60lb providing a realistic ceiling for a very good week. Five swims along a single bank, all positioned to cover the two main gravel areas and the marginal zones that the fish patrol consistently.
Accommodation is a Tiny House right at the water's edge, a practical, comfortable base with electricity, gas hob, a fridge, and a double bed. The current owner Fabrice is in the process of upgrading and replacing it, so the setup may well have improved further by the time you arrive. The bait shop at the Noute reception covers the essentials without needing to bring everything from home.
"Had a fantastic week at Noute 1 last week. Fishing was brilliant. Landed 69 carp. Best ones attached." Noute 1 angler review
Loire / Centre (Loiret), France
Grand Cerf
4 acres · Record 65lb · Average ~30lb · 4 anglers max · 4h30 from Calais
The angler who wrote this review started by saying it's not your ordinary carp fishing lake in France. It's on another level. That's a line worth pausing on, because it comes from someone who clearly knows their venues. Grand Cerf is four acres of reed-fringed water in the Loiret, managed by David and his son Natan, and what sets it apart is the combination of things done right all at once: the surroundings, the facilities, the fish, and the people running it.
The lodge is spotless and well equipped: air conditioning, heating, dual hob, microwave, fridge-freezer, two bedrooms, a separate shower room and toilet. But equally worth noting is what surrounds it. During the day: birds, horses, donkeys. After dark: owls calling, deer moving through. It's the kind of natural backdrop that reminds you why fishing in France still feels different from fishing anywhere else.
Seventeen takes over the week, 15 landed, ranging from 27 to 50lb, a mix of mirrors and commons, with fully scaleds making an appearance, and a ghosty to finish things off. With 120 carp averaging around 30lb in four acres, the fishing here has proper quality. The owner, David, is described as great company; shared food, shared wine, the kind of week that gets remembered for more than the catches.
"What an amazing place this little gem is. The wildlife was absolutely amazing: birds, horses, donkeys during the day, owls and deer at night. 17 takes, 15 landed, 27 to 50lb. The highlights were the fullys, and I even managed a ghosty. Superb food and wine with David and Natan. Hopefully there will be more trips like this in the future." Grand Cerf angler reviewView Grand Cerf, Full Details
Lorraine (Meurthe-et-Moselle), France
Harris Lake
12 acres · Record 62lb · 8 anglers max · 4h from Calais
The conditions during this particular session at Harris Lake were as tough as it gets: a cold northerly blowing all week, nights dropping below freezing, daytime temperatures barely reaching double figures. Not the kind of week you plan for, and not the kind of week that flatters most venues. Harris Lake still produced over 30 carp.
What makes that number significant is the quality behind it. Nine fish over 40lb. The biggest a 56lb mirror. An average across the session close to 35lb. On a water running cold and pressured by unfavourable winds, that kind of consistency speaks to a strong, healthy stock and a lake that fishes well across a wider range of conditions than most.
The lakeside cottage has been fully refurbished: kitchen with hob and oven, fridge and freezer for food and bait, hot shower, solar-powered electricity. A power issue came up during the stay and an engineer was on-site quickly to resolve it: worth noting for what it says about how the venue is managed. The lake sits in quiet woodland, genuinely away from everything. The angler's advice for those visiting: use the lake pellets, fish the margins and the islands tight, and track where the fish are holding. In this case, deep water near the outlet. The marginal fishing was consistent throughout.
"Extremely challenging weather all week. However the lake still produced over 30 fish: 9 over 40lb, biggest 56lb, average close to 35lb. One of the great things about the lake is you are really away from everything, left in peace to enjoy it. We would definitely return." Harris Lake angler review
Mayenne, France
The Carp Lodge
2 acres · Record 68lb · Average 30lb+ · 3 anglers max · Peninsula lodge
The Carp Lodge is a specific kind of venue: two acres, 75 carp, a 24m² lodge on a central peninsula that lets you fish the entire lake from a single position. It's not the place you go for a relentless runs week. The fish here are quality: one Common at 68lb, a Mirror at 61lb, four others over 50lb, the rest all over 22lb with an average around 30lb. One in three has spectacular scaling. Seven fish to 43lb in a week is a session that delivers, and one of those was a fully scaled mirror, a new personal best for the angler on that measure alone.
What makes The Carp Lodge stand out in reviews, beyond the fishing, is Clement. The reviews mention him consistently: friendly, informative, good English, gives you a tour and a bottle of wine on arrival, brings fresh produce from the garden through the week. The kind of owner who genuinely adds to the experience without getting in the way of it.
The wildlife at this venue has been recorded properly: 25 different bird species during one stay. Red squirrels visible from the bank. Kingfishers. The lake itself is naturally overgrown and unmanicured: you fish around snags, read the structure, stay on your game. Not a water that gives catches away. But when you land something here, it tends to be worth the effort.
"Just wanted to say what a lovely holiday I had on Carp Lodge last week. Clement was friendly and informative. The wildlife and tranquillity of the lake is second to none. 25 different bird species recorded. Also red squirrels and more. The fishing was tough but managed seven to 43lb. The largest was a stunning fully scaled, a new PB for me. I fully recommend this lake." The Carp Lodge angler review
"Four very different lakes. Four very different weeks. Something worth talking about at each one."
Every venue on the Majestic Carp portfolio goes through a selection process before it opens to bookings: stock, setting, facilities, management. These four reviews are a reminder of what that process is actually trying to produce: sessions that anglers want to come back from and tell people about. Whether it's 69 carp or seven that stick in the memory, the common thread is that something real happened.
Browse the full selection at majestic-carp.co.uk

